Skip to content.

theOneliner.com Imagine Me & You review: Tepid and inoffensive romcom. 3/5.

Essentially, Imagine Me & You is much the same love triangle drama we've seen umpteen times before with all the requisite conflicts and guilt and unrequited love based mumping of gums... but with girls kissing! Boy, Heck (Matthew Goode), marries girl, Rachel (Piper Perabo), who meets other girl, Luce (Lena Headey). Cue repression of emotions in that terribly British way leading to much angst, crises and eventual resolution. There's little wrong with the film barring a nagging sense of familiarity, with the leads giving fairly effective and believable turns. The 'com' part of the deal is wisely shuffled out to the supporting characters who do well enough, but this is far heavier on the whole 'com' element. Serviceable enough, but I can't give you much of a reason to go for this film over any of its genre stablemates.

| Click here to skip to main content |
theOneliner.com
Floats our boatfloats our boat
- 10 reasons CGI sucks - comments about Gollum aside, this article I stumbled upon sums up wonderfully how I feel about CGI in films
- "It's been a magical evening," Joel says as the Great Khali hits the Undertaker with a dustbin lid.
Gets our goatgets our goat
- Meet the Spartans - rarely, if ever, have I felt such antipathy toward a film due to the trailer alone. Avoid, I urge you.
- Unfathomable.
Now Showing
Imagine Me & You
Tepid and inoffensive romcom.
3 / 5
2005, UK-12A
Reviewed 02 Jul 2006 by Scott Morris@theoneliner.com
Essentially, Imagine Me & You is much the same love triangle drama we've seen umpteen times before with all the requisite conflicts and guilt and unrequited love based mumping of gums... but with girls kissing! Boy, Heck (Matthew Goode), marries girl, Rachel (Piper Perabo), who meets other girl, Luce (Lena Headey). Cue repression of emotions in that terribly British way leading to much angst, crises and eventual resolution. There's little wrong with the film barring a nagging sense of familiarity, with the leads giving fairly effective and believable turns. The 'com' part of the deal is wisely shuffled out to the supporting characters who do well enough, but this is far heavier on the whole 'com' element. Serviceable enough, but I can't give you much of a reason to go for this film over any of its genre stablemates.
Imagine Me & You image

The most interesting thing about Imagine Me and You, which I feel I should warn you is in fact not interesting in the slightest, is that it was trailed (in the U.K. at least) for around four-and-one-half thousand years before vanishing utterly. Having quietly shuffled off the rotunda of memory, it came as something of a surprise to see it resurface its ultimately unremarkable head. Still, Girls Kissing, eh, phwoar nudge nudge wink wink say no more what's it like.

The girls referred to in this case being the newly wed Rachel (Piper Perabo) and florist Luce (Lena Headey), the two meeting at Rachel's wedding to Heck (Matthew Goode) and doing the whole love at first sight thing. Of course, with everybody being frightfully English about the whole thing these feelings are immediately repressed and buried under layers of tea and civility.

You can, I assume, fill in the rest of the love triangle based plot details yourself from the usual template, with the minor variation of the sexual orientation of the affected star-crossed lovers. For your records, the conflicts here are a) Rachel not wishing to hurt Heck, b) Luce not wishing to break up any established relationship and c) Rachel not wishing to succumb to the love that dare not speak its name.

Imagine Me & You image

It's billed, in some quarters at least as a romcom, although it's certainly far heavier on the 'rom' than the 'com' part of that bastard conjunction. As these things go, it's not too badly handled, Headey and Perabo having a believable chemistry, with the decaying relationship betwixt Heck and Rachel shown in a reasonably sensible light. The 'com' part is left up largely to the supporting cast, Heck's philandering mate Cooper (Darren Boyd) and Heck's parents, the overwhelmingly brusque and bossy Tessa (U.K. telly-lynchpin Celia Imrie) and Ned (Anthony Head), who appears to be punch-drunk or suffering somesuch befuddlement. It would be a poor lookout for someone watching this purely on comic potential, but having heeded these words this will no longer be you.

As a straight drama (...must...resist...urge...to...make...cheap...pun...) it's something of a mixed bag. There's nothing in particular present that ought to provoke fits of hatred to be directed towards this, although there's little to laud either. There's also damn near nothing, sexual orientation aside perhaps, that you won't have seen four-and-one-half thousand times before in other flicks.

Which drops it firmly into 'mediocre' territory. Boy, are we ever tired of that territory. Given the bewildering array of films you could be watching, if you want a unique reason to see this over all others you are fresh out of luck, boyo. Still, if you don't mind a certain familiarity with the material even before watching it for the first time, there's a certain amount of enjoyment to be scraped from Imagine Me & You's bones. The skeleton, however, you've seen before.

Still, girls kissing, eh? Phwoar, etc, etc.

Were I in the business of passing quantifiable judgements, I'd award this 3/5 TippyMarks.


Director:
Ol Parker
Cast list:
Piper Perabo (Rachel)
Lena Headey (Luce)
Matthew Goode (Heck)
Celia Imrie (Tessa)
Anthony Head (Ned)
Darren Boyd (Cooper)
Sue Johnston (Ella)
Boo Jackson (Henrietta)